Top 10 Best Pizza Places in Grand Rapids, MI (2025 Edition)
If you’re a pizza lover in the greater Grand Rapids area, you’re in luck—this city is absolutely crushing it when it comes to incredible pies. From Detroit-style squares with those crispy, caramelized edges to wood-fired Neapolitan perfection, sourdough masterpieces, and classic Sicilian thick crust, Grand Rapids has it all. How many times have you seen friends debating on social media about where to grab the best slice? We’ve scoured Yelp reviews, Reddit threads, Google ratings, Facebook and local buzz to bring you the top 10 pizza spots! These picks are based on stellar ratings, rave reviews about quality ingredients, unique styles, and that perfect combo of crust, sauce, and cheese that keeps people coming back. Whether you’re planning date night, feeding the family, or just need a late-night slice, these pizzerias deliver. We’ve been in GR since FOREVER so we know this is an Impossible Task! But here’s our best effort->
1. The Mitten Brewing Company (527 Leonard St NW)
It’s no surprise this vintage baseball-themed microbrewery scores 4.3/5 on Yelp from a whopping 827 reviews—The Mitten has won “Best Pizza” awards from local media multiple times since 2012. Locals swear by original creations like “Hog Heaven,” “Curse of the Goat,” and “Westerdog.” Can’t decide? Order the famous pizza flight featuring six different pies including the weekly special. The Mitten pairs their gourmet pizzas with World Beer Cup award-winning brews, all served in a renovated Victorian fire engine house filled with cool baseball memorabilia. Great vegan options round out the menu.
2. Quarantino’s (1444 Lake Dr SE)
Born during the pandemic (hence the clever name), this Uptown gem has exploded onto the scene with a stellar 4.6/5 rating on Yelp from 92 reviews. Quarantino’s specializes in Detroit-style pizza served in 8×10-inch pans—perfect for one or two people. Diners rave about the crispy, buttery edges and creative toppings. Their “It’s All Greektown to Me” with kalamata olives, artichokes, spinach, and feta is a crowd favorite, while the “Simply Red” keeps it classic with brick cheese and mozzarella. They’ve got excellent vegan and gluten-free options too, plus a cozy atmosphere with friendly staff that makes you feel right at home.
3. Martha’s Pizza (208 Union Ave NE)
Located in the Heritage Hill neighborhood, Martha’s earns a 4.6/5 on Yelp (52 reviews) for its handcrafted 12-inch pizzas baked in an 800-degree stone hearth oven. Using fresh dough from the neighboring Nantucket Baking Company, Martha’s offers both crispy Neapolitan and gluten-free crusts. Reddit users and locals consistently praise the “Re-Loaded Potato Pizza” (yes, it’s exactly what you think—and amazing), and “The Volcano” Hawaiian with jalapeños and sriracha. The house-made sauces and “insane” number of toppings make building your own pie an adventure. This is wood-fired pizza done right.
4. Pera Pizzeria (2224 Wealthy St SE)
This Mediterranean-inspired pizzeria opened in 2022 and quickly became a local darling, frequently appearing in “best of” lists on Yelp and Google reviews. Pera specializes in authentic wood-fired pizza made in a brick oven using the freshest organic ingredients. The Turkish-Mediterranean influence sets them apart—think unique flavor combinations you won’t find elsewhere in GR. The rustic, authentic interior makes you feel like you’re dining seaside in the Mediterranean while never leaving Wealthy Street. Perfect for adventurous eaters looking for something beyond the ordinary.
5. Harmony Brewing Company (1551 Lake Dr SE)
This Uptown brewery scores a solid 4.0/5 on Yelp from 314 reviews and has become a neighborhood favorite for its combination of craft beer and seriously good pizza. Located right on Lake Drive, Harmony Brewing pairs house-brewed beers with wood-fired pizzas that keep locals coming back. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming—perfect for grabbing a pint and a pie with friends. Reviewers consistently praise both the quality of the pizza and the rotating beer selection. Whether you’re a beer enthusiast looking for a great food pairing or a pizza lover who appreciates a good brew, Harmony delivers on both fronts.
6. Arcane Pizza (1300 Plainfield Ave NE)
Started as a wood-fired pizza truck in 2021 before opening a brick-and-mortar in the Creston neighborhood in late 2023, Arcane is for folks who aren’t afraid to try something different. Their sourdough crust is the foundation for creative pies like the “Sweet Heat” (Italian salami, hot honey, house-whipped lemon ricotta, and mild chili crisps) and “Mushroom Trio” (mushroom blend, garlic cloves, cashew ricotta, and arugula). Yelp and Reddit reviewers consistently praise the bold flavors and excellent vegan/vegetarian options. A monthly rotating special keeps regulars coming back to see what’s next.
7. Licari’s Sicilian Pizza Kitchen (3123 Leonard St NE)
With a solid 4.0/5 rating on Yelp from 315 reviews, Licari’s brings authentic Sicilian family recipes to Grand Rapids. Featured on Food Network’s “3 Days to Open with Bobby Flay,” this family-owned spot is famous for thick pan-crust Sicilian pizza with chunky sauce—served one way only, the traditional way. Reviewers call it “the best pizza in town” and rave about the house-made meatballs and signature potato chips. The modern urban casual vibe makes it perfect for everything from date night to family dinners. Bonus: they’ve got locations in both Grand Rapids and Hudsonville.
Licari’s Pizza Kitchen Facebook
8. Gino’s Pizza Eastown (1556 Wealthy St SE)
A late-night legend in Eastown with 4.7/5 on Restaurant Guru (549 reviews) and strong ratings across Yelp and Google, Gino’s is the place locals hit up when they need a slice after a night out. Open until 1-2 AM most nights (closed Mondays), this no-frills spot serves up consistently delicious, classic pizza that hits the spot every time. The New York-style slices are huge, the prices are reasonable, and the vibe is exactly what you want from a neighborhood pizza joint. Reddit users call it their go-to for quality and value, with multiple locations across GR.
9. Big Bob’s Pizza (661 Croswell Ave SE)
Billing itself as “The Cheers of East Grand Rapids,” Big Bob’s earns 4.1/5 on Yelp (127 reviews) and is beloved for its family-friendly atmosphere in Gaslight Village. The menu is ridiculously extensive—six “legendary” specialty pizzas, plus the option to build your own with 4 sizes, 4 crusts (including cauliflower), 7 sauces, and 40+ toppings. Reddit users consistently call Big Bob’s the “Best Chicago-Style Deep Dish on this side of Michigan.” Don’t miss the “briazzo”—a Chicago-style deep dish pizza stuffed with your choice of ingredients. Free popcorn, tons of microbrews, and a dog-friendly patio make it perfect for the whole family.
10. Crust 54 (4051 Chicago Dr SW, Grandville)
Sharing space with Oakestown Brewery in Grandville, Crust 54 brings the best of both worlds—authentic Chicago-style deep dish and stone-fired thin crust pizza. The pairing with Oakestown’s craft brews is perfection, making this a favorite date night or hangout spot. Choose from a variety of specialty pizzas like the BBQ Chicken thin crust or the indulgent Stuffed Spinach deep dish. It’s legendary among locals in the know and worth planning your month around.
Crust 54 Link on Oakstown Website
Honorable Mentions
Greco’s Pizza (5380 Division Ave S) – A southeast Grand Rapids institution with a 4.5/5 rating on Yelp (73 reviews), Greco’s is beloved for its specialty pizzas that pack serious flavor. The Chicken Bacon Ranch is a local favorite, while the Pesto Portofino drizzled with balsamic glaze gets rave reviews for its upscale twist on pizza night. Family-friendly and conveniently located near Craig’s Cruisers, Greco’s also serves up addictive pepperoni rolls—basically little folded pizzas that are dangerously poppable.
Carlo’s Pizza (3150 Plainfield Ave NE) – This Plainfield favorite is a local gem with a 4.6/5 rating on Google from 437 reviews and high praise on Reddit as the one pizza place everyone can agree on. Diners rave about the crispy crust, generous toppings, and savory sweet sauce that make their pizzas legit and flavorful without being overly cheesy. The quick delivery, free extras like garlic knots, and options like cheesy breadsticks add to the authentic Italian vibe.
Vitale’s (5808 Leonard St NW & Comstock Park) – A storied Grand Rapids name since 1966, Vitale’s serves authentic Sicilian recipes passed down from founder Sam Vitale. Both locations offer homemade pizzas using original recipes, with newer additions like Mexican Pizza and BBQ Pizza keeping things fresh.
Salvatore’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria (West Side) – Serving Grand Rapids since 1976, Salvatore’s “Taste of Grand Rapids” pizza has won multiple local awards. Made with Sicilian-style sauce, ham, fresh basil, onions, sausage, Romano cheese, and a cultured spice blend, it’s hometown pride on a plate.
Grand Rapids’ pizza scene is absolutely thriving, with options ranging from traditional Sicilian to innovative sourdough creations, Detroit-style squares to Chicago deep dish. Whether you’re Team Thin Crust or Team Deep Dish, there’s a spot calling your name. Which one’s your favorite? Drop a comment below or tag us on social! Want more Top 10’s? Check out our Top 10 list for the perfect spot to grab a drink after your pizza feast. Buon appetito!
